A controversy has erupted over a bronze sculpture intended to portray Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip, with the public voicing widespread criticism, claiming the likenesses are unrecognizable. The artwork, which was commissioned to honor the late royals, has sparked debate, as many argue that the figures fail to capture their true appearance, leading to growing discontent over the tribute. This dispute has ignited a broader discussion regarding the accuracy and artistic interpretation in memorials dedicated to prominent public figures.
A bronze sculpture depicting Queen Elizabeth II, Prince Philip, and two corgis has sparked public outrage, with many claiming it bears little resemblance to the late royals. Created by north Belfast artist Anto Brennan, known for his chess sets featuring prominent Northern Irish political figures, the statue was unveiled at Antrim Castle Gardens on Saturday. However, locals were quick to criticize the work, with one resident remarking, “Whoever signed that off needs their eyes tested,” reflecting widespread dissatisfaction with the tribute.
Some viewers expressed that while the representations of Prince Philip and the corgis were well-executed, the figure of Queen Elizabeth II missed the mark, with one observer noting that “there’s something not right” about it. The backlash intensified on social media, prompting the post announcing the sculpture to disable comments after a surge of ridicule. One person humorously compared the Queen’s likeness to Mrs. Doubtfire, the iconic character played by Robin Williams in the 1993 comedy. The reaction reflects widespread disapproval of the tribute.
The proposal for the bronze sculpture of Queen Elizabeth II and her corgis was initiated in January 2023, intended to complement the existing statue of Prince Philip. Deputy Mayor of Antrim and Newtownabbey, Paul Dunlop, acknowledged the varied reactions, stating, “It’s down to personal taste, everyone has their own opinion, but it is what the sculpture represents that is important.” At the unveiling, Mayor Neil Kelly described the piece as a “beautiful statue.”
However, when the council shared photos of the sculpture on Facebook, locals quickly expressed their opinions. The council’s post emphasized that the sculpture “captures Her Majesty in a dignified pose, reflecting her grace, steadfastness, and lifelong dedication to public service.” It also highlighted the sculpture’s significance, standing alongside the statue of Prince Philip in the Parterre Garden of Antrim Castle Gardens, commemorating the Queen who passed on September 8, 2022.
The council’s description of the sculpture noted, “To complete the scene, the royal couple is joined by two of the more than 30 dogs that Her Majesty owned during her lifetime.” However, public reaction was far less positive. One commenter sarcastically remarked, “At least the dogs look good,” while another joked, “Think you need to ask Temu for your money back.”
Criticism continued with one person comparing the Queen’s likeness to Mrs. Doubtfire, while others found the piece outright offensive. One individual called for the statues to be “removed and melted down and redone,” deeming it an “insult” to the Queen. Another agreed, saying it was “definitely not the tribute she deserved.” The backlash included harsh assessments like “absolutely beyond dreadful” and “utterly ridiculous,” with a local adding that while the likeness of Prince Philip was passable, the depiction of Queen Elizabeth was “shocking.”
In the midst of widespread criticism, one supporter defended the artist, stating, “Such a shame people can only find fault in these, but don’t think about the time and effort this guy has put into making them.”
Lord-Lieutenant of County Antrim, Mr. David McCorkell KStJ, who was appointed as Her Majesty’s Personal Representative for the County in 2019, expressed his honor at attending the statue’s unveiling. Reflecting on Queen Elizabeth II’s reign, he remarked, “Queen Elizabeth II will forever be remembered for a life dedicated to duty and for her sustained and selfless service, stretching over 70 years.”
He continued, “Seeing these statues alongside each other today not only preserves that bond and ensures her legacy as our longest-reigning monarch lives on for future generations, but also highlights the connection between her and her Consort, His Royal Highness The Duke of Edinburgh.” McCorkell concluded with, “It remains my greatest privilege to have been Her Majesty’s humble servant. May she rest in peace.”
