Gabby Allen and Casey O’Gorman have been officially crowned the winners of Love Island: All Stars 2025. The couple clinched the substantial £50,000 prize during Monday night’s final, surpassing runners-up Luca Bish and Grace Jackson. After three prior appearances on the show, Casey ultimately achieved his desired outcome, securing his happy ending with blonde bombshell Gabby.
Ekin-Su Culculoglu and Curtis Pritchard secured third place, while Catherine Agbaje and Omar Nyame finished in fourth. Elma Pazar and Sammy Root rounded out the top five in Love Island: All Stars 2025.
Throughout his time on Love Island, Casey O’Gorman has had a number of different partners. In his debut appearance on the show in 2023, he was coupled with Lana Jenkins, Claudia Fogarty, and Rosie Seabrook.
During his appearance on the first season of Love Island: All Stars, Casey O’Gorman was coupled up with Kaz Kamwi and Eve Gale.
In the final, as Maya Jama interviewed the last two couples, Gabby Allen reflected on her unexpected friendship with ex-boyfriend Marcel, admitting, “I never thought I would be friends with him. I can unblock him on Instagram now, we can be friends.”
When asked about whether he “chases the clout,” Casey jokingly responded, “Can we not mention that word ever again, please?”
Before the winners were revealed, last year’s champions, Tom Clare and Molly Smith—who is also Casey’s best friend—joined via video call to wish the final couples the best of luck. They expressed excitement about the possibility of double dates once Casey and Gabby return home, offering nothing but support and positivity for the new couple.
The finale sparked a mixed response from fans on X (formerly Twitter). While some expressed their joy at Casey and Gabby’s win, with comments like, “SOOOOOOO happy Gabby n Casey won!!! LOVE THEM #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars #AllStars,” others voiced disappointment with the outcome.
Some fans were ecstatic with the outcome, with one writing, “So happy for WINNERS … #GabbyAndCasey They had our votes. Really want this to be a #LoveIsland Happy Ever After!” Another added, “You know what… I ain’t even mad at Casey and Gabby winning.” A third commenter praised the couple’s natural connection, saying, “Well done Casey and Gabby. The only couple that didn’t look like they were trying too hard and seemed to have a truly natural connection with each other. All the best. Hope it works out.”
However, not all viewers shared the same sentiment. Some expressed their disappointment, with one fan tweeting, “Let me add to the thread – The worst Love Island All Stars winners,” while another wrote, “Okay what just happened? Abeg Gabby & Casey?!? Oh hell naw…”
Despite the shock loss, Ekin-Su Culculoglu expressed contentment, saying, “I’m really happy, I’ve found my man.” Curtis Pritchard reflected on his relationship with Ekin-Su, noting, “I just remember us having extremely intense eye contact, genuinely she surprised me along the way.”
In their exit interview, Catherine Agbaje sweetly admitted that she had “prayed” for someone like Omar Nyame to come into the villa, quipping that “good things come to those who wait.”#newsafro_
